The smartest thing about Cincinnati’s electrical scooter rental program is you can seize a scooter at Point A, experience it to Point B, and simply depart it there. No must carry it again, and no want both to place it right into a dock. The sidewalk will do.
The worst factor about Cincinnati’s electrical scooter rental program is you can seize a scooter at Point A, experience it to Point B, and simply depart it there. No must carry it again, and no want both to place it right into a dock. The sidewalk will do.
As Evanston actively considers having an electrical scooter rental program right here, lessons from other communities on what works and what doesn’t might assist Evanston keep away from issues which have plagued other locations.
Take Cincinnati, for instance, the place I used to be a reporter for a few years and returned for a Memorial Day weekend go to.
While the scooter rental program is extremely widespread, with the two-wheeled autos zipping round city, there have been so many negatives that the Queen City lately notified the 2 scooter franchisees that the entire program would possibly simply be scrapped.
![](https://evanstonnow.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/scooter-2-1024x576.jpg)
According to a metropolis e-mail obtained by radio station WVXU, “the City Administration, in response to mounting e-scooter-program-associated issues, is considering the possibility of terminating the e-scooter program and banning the e-scooters from operating in the city.”
While it appears unlikely the favored program will certainly be ended, Cincinnati minimize scooter program hours from 6 a.m. to 11 p.m. to six a.m. to six p.m., as talks with franchisees Bird and Lime are ongoing to resolve the troubles.
Many of these troubles are apparent, unlawful, and you may’t miss them. Riding on sidewalks. Riding after curfew. Underage using. Leaving the scooters in a method that they block pedestrian site visitors (“Intrusive Parking,” in accordance with an e-mail to Evanston Now from Cincinnati’s Department of Transportation and Engineering). And using the unsuitable method on a one-way avenue.
Not solely that, however “Riding while in support of, and engaged in Criminal Activity,” was additionally talked about in Cincinnati’s e-mail to Evanston Now.
Cara Pratt, Evanston’s director of sustainability and resilience, is engaged on bringing an e-scooter program right here. Before taking the job in Evanston, Pratt labored in Racine, Wisconsin, and helped arrange the e-scooter program there final summer time.
Pratt tells Evanston Now that she met lately with representatives of Lyft, the corporate that has Evanston’s Divvy Bike franchise, and has “right of first refusal” on including e-scooters, if Evanston leaders need such autos.
Pratt says Lyft steered having a docked scooter program right here, versus the “dockless/leave it almost anywhere” system seen in Cincinnati and other locations.
A docked program could be just like Divvy Bike, the place you pay for a sure period of time, however should return the scooter to a everlasting dock quite than depart it on the sidewalk.
While that could be much less handy for riders, it additionally minimizes “scooter clutter,” the place unused two-wheeled autos get in the way in which of two-legged pedestrians.
Racine has a “dockless” program, however Pratt says the town there employed two individuals to maneuver scooters that had been left within the unsuitable spots.
“We got calls from residents who didn’t want scooters parked in front of their houses,” Pratt says.
She says Racine was dedicated to “having an abundance of places” the place leaving a scooter was OK, similar to close to gentle poles, so long as the scooters weren’t on the street.
Cincinnati’s dockless program permits scooters to be left on the sidewalk, however the autos are purported to be parked upright, and out of pedestrian movement.
Both cities enable scooters on bike paths. Otherwise, they’re purported to be ridden on the road.
A Racine lesson Evanston would possibly have a look at is limiting the variety of scooters, and even limiting the variety of franchisees.
Racine, which has in regards to the same-sized inhabitants as Evanston, has a 100-scooter cap for its pilot program with a single scooter agency (Bird).
Cincinnati, which has 4 occasions the inhabitants (300,000) permits a complete of 800 scooters, 400 per franchisee. If you assume the scooters are all over the place in downtown Cincinnati, you’re not far from unsuitable.
Cincinnati additionally requires the franchisees to gather the scooters after curfew, retailer them after which put them again out within the morning. The electrical autos do should be recharged, so some form of assortment is important, until the scooters are left in docks that could possibly be charger-equipped.
There are some technological options which may be added to scooters, and maybe mandated by a metropolis. One characteristic routinely stops the scooter from working at a set time (similar to curfew hour).
Another, known as “geo-fencing,” can shut a scooter down if it enters a prohibited space, similar to a sidewalk. And there are additionally methods to require proof of age in an app and credit score/card-based rental system, to ensure customers are over 18.
After Cincinnati tightened its scooter curfew, a represenative for Bird issued a media assertion saying partly “Shared e-scooters are a critical, eco-friendly transportation alternative…”
The assertion added that Bird has already activated an ID scan to confirm age and stated the corporate desires to work with the Cincinnati officers, hoping the “City will retract its decision to implement a curfew which penalizes … tens of thousands of responsible riders….”
In Evanston, Pratt says there will certainly be public enter earlier than the town decides whether or not to maneuver ahead with an e-scooter program, and in that case, how it could function.
Evanston has already requested Lyft for price estimates for each a docked and dockless system.
“Lyft will do whatever we want them to do,” Pratt says.
Assuming all of the questions are resolved, and the Evanston City Council indicators off on an working plan, Pratt says “it’s possible to have scooters by fall,” presumably in a pilot to iron out the bugs.
One factor that can at all times be troublesome, regardless of the system, is enforcement.
Cincinnati has a $100 effective for scooter ordinance violations.
But police priorities don’t embody chasing scooter-riding-millenials down the sidewalk.
According to Cincinnati’s Department of Transportation and Engineering, “We are not actively issuing tickets to e-Scooter riders.”