We not too long ago had a reader e-mail CleanTechnica asking us to share an concept. In brief, they stated the United States authorities ought to provide $500 rebates on e-bikes or different types of electrical micromobility. The concept can be to get extra individuals out of automobiles, particularly gas-powered automobiles. Reducing demand for gasoline couldn’t solely drop gasoline costs, however might additionally preserve the US from needing to purchase Russian oil, which funds Putin’s warfare in opposition to Ukraine.
In this text, I wish to discover this concept additional, and enhance upon it a bit. Our reader’s coronary heart is unquestionably in the best place, and it’s a step in the best route. This concept is a giant a part of the one sane and workable resolution, not just for the United States, however for different international locations dealing with Russia points. We additionally want to contemplate methane (CNG and LNG), as that is an excellent tougher drawback.
One Counterargument: Increase Supply Instead Of Lowering Demand
When the Ukraine War began, and US gasoline costs shot up towards European ranges, there have been many differing takes on this. For some, it was seen as a great factor, as a result of it might velocity up EV adoption. For others, the ache was simply an excessive amount of and so they wished to do something to get costs down. And then we had this take by Elon Musk:
Hate to say it, however we have to enhance oil & gasoline output instantly.
Extraordinary occasions demand extraordinary measures.
— Elon Musk (@elonmusk) March 5, 2022
Yes, costs are set by provide and demand, and when the United States reduce off imports of Russian oil (which accounted for perhaps 3% of the general provide), that damage much more. But, we additionally need to remember that the US provide of oil isn’t some knob or lever some grasping tycoon can pull or flip to open up the availability of oil, and that costs could be affected closely by OPEC. Let’s check out why oil provide is tougher to take care of than demand.
The Problem With This: Increasing Production Is Challenging
Domestic oil comes from quite a lot of sources. Before we speak about them, let’s speak about easy oil wells. There’s a gap punched into the earth all the way down to the place the oil is, and a pump is used to suck the oil up and out. You’d assume that whenever you shut one in every of these down, you would simply drive over and get it going once more by opening the valves and hooking the pump again up, proper? Well, not a lot.
As Oilman Magazine factors out, it’s not practically that straightforward. When demand drops, and oil corporations shut off wells to remain worthwhile, they are often positioned in quite a lot of statuses.
Some are energetic, however are deliberately producing much less oil than they will. These are the simplest to get extra oil out of, since you simply have to pump extra oil (both by the nicely’s velocity or what number of hours per day you’ve it pumping). But normally, a nicely that they don’t wish to get a lot out of will likely be inactive and so they’ll simply pump extra at different wells to provide what they wish to be extra worthwhile. In different phrases, these aren’t widespread in any respect.
Among inactive wells, there are ones which can be actually simply turned off, people who have a few of their gear eliminated however are in any other case able to pump, people who want some refurbishment work, and people which can be deserted and/or plugged up as a result of the oil firm determined to shut it completely or went out of enterprise. Among the wells which can be simpler to place again into service, there are wells which can be costlier to function, and thus aren’t worthwhile when oil costs are low, however could be reactivated when costs rise once more.
When costs rise or another issue results in an increase in manufacturing, there will likely be some oil capability that may enhance fairly fast, however that isn’t a lot. Most wells would require weeks, months, and even years to get capability going once more.
So, let’s put ourselves within the oil man’s footwear for a bit. You’re deciding whether or not to reopen a nicely. Everyone and their canine desires the oil, even Elon Musk. So, you run the numbers on reopening some wells to present them the oil and make some bucks. The simple wells? Yeah, these are a no brainer. But the wells that might take months or years to get going both for the primary time or once more, that’s a more durable monetary choice. If you make investments cash in opening or reopening wells, after which costs drop once more in just a few months when the battle eases up or demand drops, you’re going to be caught along with your shorts down.
This drawback is even worse for issues like Canadian tar sands. The individuals crying for the opening of extra US-Canada pipelines don’t understand that they’re fed by oil that isn’t worthwhile until oil may be very costly. So, when costs drop, these sources of oil would shut off once more, and the pipelines can be dry once more till oil goes again up in value. So, that’s not a silver bullet, both.
In different phrases, if you need oil corporations to make extra oil, you’d higher be capable of show to them that they’re not going to get hosed later. To do this, you’ll have to guarantee them that there will likely be sturdy demand and in lots of instances continued excessive oil costs to justify the manufacturing. The reality is, we are able to’t actually guarantee them of that proper now.
So, no, making an attempt to regulate costs and preserve from shopping for Russian oil isn’t a easy matter of opening the US oil spigots and filling the barrels and pipelines up. The value, time, and long-term profitability points for oil wells makes growing U.S. provide a less-than-ideal to unworkable resolution to fixing the issue of Russian oil and value volatility.
What You’ll Find In Part 2
Pointing out that “Drill, baby, drill!” isn’t the reply actually doesn’t reply the decision of our readers who requested us to cowl this. We additionally want to supply an answer. In Part 2, I’m going to develop on the thought of micromobility rebates or tax credit, and clarify that oil is simply a small a part of American and European vulnerability to Russian power.
Featured picture by Jennifer Sensiba.
Appreciate CleanTechnica’s originality? Consider changing into a CleanTechnica Member, Supporter, Technician, or Ambassador — or a patron on Patreon.