Welcome to EURACTIV’s Digital Brief, your weekly replace on all issues digital within the EU. You can subscribe to the publication right here.
“Our goal with the DGA was to set the foundation for a data economy people and businesses can trust in. Only if trust and fairness are guaranteed, data sharing can flourish to its fullest potential and stimulate new business models and social innovation”
-Angelika Niebler, European Parliament’s rapporteur for the Data Governance Act
Story of the week: DGA moves ahead. EU legislators have reached a remaining settlement compromise on the Data Governance Act (DGA), the primary legislative initiative of the European Data Strategy. The new laws will introduce guidelines for buying and selling knowledge and set up a governance construction for the European knowledge areas. A key position within the knowledge marketplaces might be performed by knowledge intermediaries, which should adjust to particular obligations to make sure truthful entry to industrial knowledge. The DGA additionally consists of anti-bundling measures forcing suppliers of for-provide knowledge intermediation providers to maintain them commercially separate for different providers, notably cloud providers.
Data altruist organisations have additionally been launched, to provide authorized standing to these organisations that alternate knowledge for the general public good, for example, analysis on local weather change or medication. A Data Innovation Board might be established, together with members of educational, analysis, business and civil society. The Board will work on widespread technical options for requirements and interoperability and can advise the Commission on technical necessities for knowledge exchanges and storage.
The most controversial chapter of the deal was most likely the entry to public sector knowledge, which might want to safeguard private knowledge safety and mental property rights. These safeguards can even should be in place when exchanging knowledge with organisations based mostly in third nations. Following the GDPR mannequin, the Commission will undertake adequacy selections for worldwide knowledge transfers with particular nations. Read extra.
Don’t miss: The Slovenian presidency circulated a compromise textual content on the draft AI Act this week, proposing vital adjustments to the textual content. In phrases of scope, any AI system for army use has been excluded, restating the precept that nationwide safety is an unique competency of member states.
The presidency proposed extending the ban on social scoring to personal entities and expanded the definition of prohibited use additionally to use social and financial situations. These measures mixed may need a major affect on the monetary sector. There additionally appears to be a contradiction within the textual content, because the estimation of insurance coverage premiums was added beneath high-risk purposes.
On biometric recognition, the adjective ‘remote’ was deleted because it was thought of too tough to outline. The instance used through the dialogue was {that a} policeman carrying a bodycam couldn’t be labeled as distant identification. Moreover, within the distinctive circumstances of imminent threats, actors collaborating with legislation enforcement authorities can even be capable of use biometric recognition techniques. At the identical time, the request for authorisation to the judicial authority was made timelier and stricter.
The accompanying progress report ready by the presidency this week additionally outlined a lot of points within the textual content that stay unresolved, particularly when it comes to compliances measures for SMEs and the distribution of duties throughout the AI worth chain. Read extra.
Also this week:
- IMCO and LIBE may have a co-lead on the AI Act
- Irish Council for Civil Liberties filed a criticism in opposition to the European Commission over GDPR enforcement
- The European Commission launched a proposal for a European Newsroom
- MEPs push for enlarging the scope of the widespread charger proposal
Before we begin: Raj Samani, McAfee’s chief scientist, walks us via the upcoming challenges within the discipline of cybersecurity, and the way regulators, legislation enforcement authorities and personal actors ought to work collectively to face cyberthreats.
https://www.euractiv.com/section/digital/podcast/cybersecurity-trends-and-actions/
A message by Google
Giving you extra sustainable selections with Google
People all over the world are in search of methods to do their half to assist the planet — they usually need companies to step up their efforts too. This is why lately, we shared a number of new methods folks can use Google merchandise to make sustainable selections — from selecting eco-friendly routes to looking greener flights. Continue Reading >>
Artificial Intelligence
Can we begin now? The six-month maintain up of the AI Act within the European Parliament appears to have ended this week, because the battle over competency between the parliamentary committees was lastly solved. IMCO and LIBE may have a joint lead on the file, with the respective rapporteurs Brando Benifei (S&D) and Dragoș Tudorache (Renew) having equal powers in defining the proposal. That means doubling the folks concerned, which is able to in fact end in slower progress. However, on essentially the most controversial facet of banning biometric recognition, the 2 rapporteurs appear to be largely aligned, as they’ve each voted in favour of a decision for a ban again in October.
Game over. The political distance might be far more vital with the opposite contender for the AI Act lead, JURI’s Axel Voss (EPP), who obtained out of the struggle defeated. For Voss, the choice was taken on ‘purely political grounds’, and JURI deserved the lead given its activism within the discipline of AI. However, on the difficulty of facial recognition applied sciences, the EPP appears to be remoted in Parliament. The Christian Democrats have misplaced their main political backer within the current German elections, and a setback in such a significant legislative file may additionally be seen as a sign of the centre of gravity already transferring towards the centre-left.
Competition
Giphy should go. In an unprecedented antitrust resolution, UK’s Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) ordered Meta to promote picture platform Giphy, acquired final 12 months for $400 million. For the antitrust watchdog, the deal dangers hampering competitors between social media platforms and the show promoting market, a conclusion that Meta disputes and is more likely to attraction. In October, Meta was fined $70 million for withholding details about the takeover. Read extra.
Not on my watch. The US Federal Trade Commission has launched a lawsuit to dam chip provider Nvidia from buying UK chip design supplier Arm Ltd. Amid a worldwide semiconductor scarcity, the $40bn acquisition, the FTC says, “would give one of the largest chip companies control over the computing technology and designs that rival firms rely on to develop their own competing chips”, stifling innovation in next-generation applied sciences. The deal has additionally come beneath scrutiny from different competitors authorities, together with within the EU, the place the Commission launched an investigation in October over issues that Nvidia may limit entry or implement increased costs on Arm’s applied sciences to the detriment of rivals within the sector.
Here we go once more. Publishers affiliation GESTE has filed a criticism in opposition to Apple with the French Competition Authority, alleging that the tech firm has set extreme restrictions on publishers equivalent to limiting entry to essential knowledge, self-preferencing its personal providers and implementing harsh pricing insurance policies. According to GESTE, these moves not solely threaten publishers economically but additionally pose a hazard in relation to press freedom and pluralism in France. The episode is simply the final of a protracted sequence of clashes between the French media and Big Tec.
Data & privateness
Data disappointment. A criticism in opposition to the European Commission has been lodged with the European Ombudsman by the Irish Council for Civil Liberties (ICCL) for the Commission’s alleged twin failures: to watch enforcement of the GDPR and guarantee accountability from Ireland in relation to the information safety legislation’s implementation. GDPR enforcement, or lack thereof, is the topic of a lot debate in the meanwhile: it has formed discussions on the DSA and would be the topic of a convention organised by the European Data Protection Supervisor for subsequent 12 months. Read extra.
Lawsuits allowed. Consumer teams can launch lawsuits in opposition to platforms that course of knowledge, equivalent to Facebook, for infringements of EU privateness guidelines, in keeping with an advocate basic on the EU Court of Justice. The opinion got here in response to a case initiated in opposition to Facebook by the Federation of German Consumer Organisations over the platform’s alleged failure to obviously clarify how and why private knowledge was being processed on the App Centre. Such opinions, whereas not legally binding, usually sign the possible final result of the case. Read extra.
Sanction in view. The UK’s Information Commissioner (ICO) has unveiled its provisional intent to nice controversial AI agency Clearview round £17 million, and to problem a discover that it ought to cease processing, and delete, the private knowledge of individuals within the UK after allegations that the corporate engaged in critical violations of the nation’s knowledge safety legal guidelines. The announcement was the results of an investigation by the ICO and the Australian Information Commissioner from which the ICO concluded that the photographs in Clearview’s database “are likely to include the data of a substantial number of people from the UK and may have been gathered without people’s knowledge”.
Digital Markets Act
Amendments race. ECON is ready to violate the ‘truce’ Andreas Schwab had hoped for by asking different political teams to not current separate amendments to the DMA. Rapporteur Yon-Courtian didn’t admire the truth that solely three of her amendments have been allowed within the IMCO vote. Remarkably, all three have been permitted regardless of Schwab’s EPP voting in opposition to, therefore they shouldn’t be underestimated. Yon-Courtin has already acquired the approval of the group coordinators, however the content material of the amendments isn’t but identified. Speculations embrace a stronger definition for cloud suppliers (i.e. infrastructure as a service and software program as a service), the growth of interoperability provisions together with on near-field-communication antennas, the extension of anti-bundling measures to ancillary providers. JURI can be mentioned to be engaged on amendments, however it’s not clear whether or not it has the mandatory assist.
Digital Services Act
Which DSA? After two months of stalemate, the DSA file has unexpectedly accelerated to 2 technical conferences per day and loads of new variations of compromise amendments going round. The present velocity of the negotiations leaves little or no room for dialogue, however Christel Schaldemose appears decided to succeed in an settlement in any respect prices as she dropped her most controversial proposal. The new majority appears firmly within the centre-right, together with ECR following the inclusion of provisions that will pressure platforms to reinstate content material that was taken down. Requests from different committees have additionally been largely ignored. More readability on the state of the proposal is predicted on the subsequent shadow assembly on Monday, which can be meant to be the final one if the brand new date for the IMCO vote on 13 December is to be revered.
Industrial technique
Adjust your expectations. Achieving independence in relation to semiconductor manufacturing is “not doable” in Europe, Competition Commissioner Margrethe Vestager mentioned this week. The EU has been pushing to broaden its chip-making capability amid a worldwide scarcity, however Vestager warned in opposition to setting sights too excessive, saying that “there is a different level of production capacity in Europe” and it was as an alternative vital for Europe to see itself “in a global perspective”.
International connectivity
Rebranding. After months of postponements and delays, the European Commission lastly unveiled its grand infrastructural plan, the Global Gateway, which many observers take into account the EU’s bid to rival China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI). The funds obtainable, €300 bn, is not any match for China’s BRI, whose estimated value is in trillions. As is usually the case when the Commission presents figures, it places collectively all types of funding and inflates them with some phantom ‘mobilisation of the private sector’. The initiative is subsequently little greater than a repackaging of present initiatives beneath an umbrella time period, one thing that made some observers use some disagreeable phrases (see record of steered readings).
Media
EU newsroom. The Commission is ready to fund the event of a “European Newsroom” gathering 16 information businesses to report on EU affairs in 15 languages, it was introduced this week. The unveiling of the plan got here on the second version of the European News Media Forum, which introduced collectively media sector stakeholders to debate the way forward for the business. The newsroom will launch in January and is meant to bolster a multilingual European info house. Read extra.
Major merger. Debate is ongoing in France over a deal that will see the nation’s two main TV teams, TF1 and M6, merge to type a media big on par with US titans equivalent to Netflix. The head of one of many group’s mother or father corporations defended the merger earlier than Senators this week, however the French competitors authority and superior audio-visual council have but to problem an opinion, and antitrust issues stay widespread. Read extra.
Call for denunciation. Reporters Without Borders (RSF) has known as on the Commission and Parliament to “firmly denounce” a defamation legislation lately handed in Greece. The legislation, described by RSF as an “attack on press freedom”, criminalises “fake news which may cause anxiety and fear to the citizens”. RSF objects to the felony penalties and worries that the obscure wording of the legislation leaves room for the potential prosecution of journalists for publishing authentic materials. Read extra.
Platforms
Platforms on their toes. Gig economic system platforms haven’t missed any likelihood to specific their issues for the upcoming Commission’s directive for regulating the platform economic system, due subsequent Wednesday. The worries have been fuelled by a leaked model of the proposal from final month, which fits in a really comparable path because the parliament’s own-initiative report from September. What platforms worry essentially the most is the so-called rebuttable presumption of employment, which might flip most gig staff into staff except the platforms show in any other case. However, political assist for these measures appears very robust, as proven in an open letter signed by a number of employment ministries and MEPs.
TikTok transparency. TikTok has launched a sequence of latest transparency experiences this week, detailing the requests submitted to them by exterior events. In addition to setting out the variety of take-down notices it issued over mental property violations, the platform recorded a large spike in authorities removing requests within the first half of 2021, the information reveals, with requests to take away or limit content material or accounts ballooning to 2,434 between January and June this 12 months, in comparison with the 412 registered within the second half of 2020. Almost 1,900 such requests got here from Russia alone. Law enforcement requests for info on customers additionally grew on this interval, although not as steeply. Almost 2,000 requests have been submitted in contrast with simply over 1,000 within the earlier six months, which itself was a decline from the previous interval. The proportion of emergency, versus authorized, requests, grew, nevertheless.
Twin transitions
Charger growth sought. EU lawmakers from throughout political teams got here collectively to push for an growth of the scope of the Commission’s initiative to harmonise chargers. MEPs pushed for the legislative proposal to incorporate wi-fi chargers, laptops, smartwatches and different digital recommendation throughout its consideration within the IMCO Committee this week. The Commission, nevertheless, has resisted the adjustments, for essentially the most half citing technical challenges. Read extra.
What else we’re studying this week:
Ireland’s the Wrong Privacy Watchdog for Europe (The Washington Post)
Why bullshit guidelines in Brussels (The Economist)
The massive thought: Should we fear about synthetic intelligence? (The Guardian)